RESTRICTIONS ON RELIGIOUS FREEDOM DURING THE RUSSIAN-UKRAINIAN WAR: TRANSFORMATION OF VALUE FOUNDATIONS
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.31392/cult.alm.2025.2.57Keywords:
religious freedom, national security, human rights, freedom of conscience, Ukrainian Orthodoxy, Russian-Ukrainian warAbstract
The article examines the transformation of the value foundations of religious freedom in Ukraine under conditions of full-scale Russian aggression. The author analyzes the paradigmatic shift from a liberal model of religious freedom as an absolute value to a securitized model, where security becomes the determining criterion for the permissibility of religious activity.The study reveals the evolution of approaches to religious freedom in Ukraine – from an optimistic vision as an indisputable achievement of democracy to awareness of its vulnerability under hybrid threats. Special attention is paid to the use of religious institutions as instruments of hybrid warfare and the formation of a new legal regime in response to these challenges.Applying the theoretical developments of the Copenhagen School of Security Studies, the author explores the process of securitization of religion in the Ukrainian context, highlighting its specific characteristics: the existential nature of the threat, institutional dependence as a security factor, and the preventive nature of securitization.The article analyzes the international community's reaction to Ukrainian restrictions on the activities of religious organizations associated with the aggressor country, and reveals the complexity of balancing traditional human rights principles with recognition of Ukraine's security needs.The author problematizes the formation of a new paradigm of "security as a prerequisite for freedom," which is based on rethinking the hierarchy of rights under conditions of existential threat. Special attention is paid to the process of institutionalizing a new approach to regulating the activities of religious organizations associated with the aggressor country.The study is of significant importance for understanding the transformation of the relationship between individual rights and collective security in the era of hybrid threats and may serve as a foundation for rethinking international standards of religious freedom under conditions of existential challenges.
References
Бабій, М. (1996). Свобода віросповідання: проблеми практичної реалізації. Українське релігієзнавство, 1, 45–50.
Brylov, D., & Kalenychenko, T. (2022). Ukrainian Religious Actors and Organizations After Russia's Invasion. Berkley Center for Religion, Peace & World Affairs.
Buzan, B., Wæver, O., & de Wilde, J. (1998). Security: A New Framework for Analysis. Lynne Rienner Publishers.
Canopy Forum. (2024, November 27). Religious Freedom in Ukraine: Can we move on from misleading election narratives? URL: https://canopyforum.org/2024/11/27/religious-freedom-in-ukraine-can-we-move-on-from-misleading-election-narratives/
Василенко, В. С., & Корицький, Я. Б. (2025). Сутність держави як фактор вдосконалення державно-церковних відносин. Культурологічний альманах, 1(13), 9–15.
Vasin, M. (2016). Огляд ініціатив у сфері розвитку релігійного законодавства України. Релігійна Свобода: На Перехресті Епох, Країн і Культур. Науковий Щорічник. № 19(1), 180–184. https://doi.org/10.32420/RS.2016.19.1.965
Vovk, D. (2024). The Russia-Ukraine war, the Orthodox Church, and religious freedom. Religion, State and Society. Vol. 52
Єленський, В. (2023, 8 грудня). Ви потрапили під вплив інформаційного кліше, що поширюється керівництвом УПЦ та їхніми лобістами. Діалог Тут. URL: https://dialogtut.online/vy-potrapyly-pid-vplyv-informaczijnogo-klishe-shho-poshyryuyetsya-kerivnycztvom-upcz-ta-yihnimy-lobistamy/
Fert, A. Vovk, Dm. (2024). Spiritual Decolonization, National Security, and Religious Freedom. Talk About: Law and Religion.
Филипович, Л. (2024). Сучасні виклики для України в сфері релігійної безпеки. Історія релігій в Україні, 34, 210–220.
Human Rights Watch. (2024, October 30). Ukraine: New Law Raises Religious Freedom Concerns.
Колодний, А. (2013). Феномен українського релігійного плюралізму. Релігійна свобода, 19, 11–20.
Целковський, Г. А. (2024). Міжнародний аспект правового регулювання підпорядкування Української православної церкви. Культурологічний альманах, (3), 370–377. https://doi.org/10.31392/cult.alm.2024.3.44
Laegaard, S. (2019). Religious toleration and securitisation of religion. In M. C. d. C. Andreescu (Ed.), Religion and Human Security: A Global Perspective (pp. 117–134). Routledge.
OSCE/ODIHR. (2019). Freedom of Religion or Belief and Security: Policy Guidance. Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe.
Pennsylvania Assembly. (1755, November 11). Reply to the Governor. Founders Online, National Archives.
U.S. Commission on International Religious Freedom. (2024). Annual Report 2024.
U.S. Department of State. (2023). 2023 Report on International Religious Freedom: Ukraine.
Vasin, M. (2023). New Religious Legislation in Ukraine as a Response to Russian Aggression. SECURITY, RELIGION, AND THE RULE OF LAW International Perspectives. Edited by Tania Pagotto, Joshua M. Roose and G. P. Marcar (pp. 126–138). Routledge.
Wittes, B. (2011). Against a crude balance: Platform security and the hostile symbiosis between liberty and security. Brookings Institution.
Хельберг, У. І. (2012). Сек'юритизація як політичний феномен. Маґістеріум. [упоряд.: Кисельов С. О.]. Політичні студії. Вип. 46. С. 64–67.
Ярмол, Л. В. (2015). Захист свободи віросповідання Європейським судом з прав людини (загальнотеоретичні аспекти). Л. В. Ярмол, І. Б. Тучапець. Вісник Національного університету "Львівська політехніка". Серія : Юридичні науки. № 824. С. 368–372.